← Back to blog

Rental Application Criteria in SA: What Landlords Can Assess

November 16, 2026
Rental Application Criteria in SA: What Landlords Can Assess

In South Australia, a landlord can assess a rental applicant on identity, ability to pay the rent, suitability for the tenancy and, within limits, rental history. The application must use Form A1, and the law caps the documents you can ask for. A tenant selection process built on written, objective criteria applied the same way to every applicant protects the asset and keeps you clear of a discrimination complaint. At HOSO Real Estate in Adelaide, our HPTS Tenant Screening is a 4-layer system built around that principle.

HOSO Real Estate
Support for Tenant Selection
HOSO Real Estate provides tenant leasing and compliance management for Adelaide landlords seeking professional oversight of their rental properties.
Visit

TL;DR

  • Applications must use Form A1, and the form states the weekly rent and the bond amount, if any.
  • You may require no more than two documents each for identity, ability to pay rent and suitability to enter the agreement.
  • Past tenancy disputes, unredacted bank statements, social media, medical records and the reason for moving are all off limits.
  • Protected characteristics such as age, race, disability, pregnancy and caring responsibilities must never influence a decision.
  • Set your criteria before the first inspection, apply them to every applicant, and keep a written record of why you chose the successful one.

Table of Contents

What the SA rules allow you to ask

The SA Government's guidance on choosing a tenant sets the baseline. A landlord or agent may ask about the applicant's identity, contact details, who is likely to live in the property, previous rental details (but not disputes) and how long they plan to rent.

Financial and employment requests are narrower. You may ask for a redacted bank or financial statement, a payslip or employment confirmation, or another document that directly shows financial capacity. No more than two documents can be required in each category.

The application itself is standardised. Form A1 is the required format, and it must state the weekly rent payable and the bond amount. The regulation behind it, regulation 8 of the Residential Tenancies Regulations 2025, caps requests at two documents each for identity verification, ability to pay rent and suitability to enter the tenancy agreement.

The Youth Law Australia guide to starting a tenancy in SA describes how this looks to an applicant. They can be asked for up to two identity documents, at least one with a photo, and up to two documents showing they can pay. The form also asks for two referees, and the landlord may check prior rental history against the databases listed on the form.

What the SA rules allow you to ask

What you cannot request

Regulation 8 lists information a landlord may not ask for. It is worth reading as a checklist against your current application process, particularly if you inherited paperwork from an earlier manager or an older template.

You may not request:

  • details of past legal action or tenancy disputes
  • termination notices that did not end a tenancy
  • whether the bond is being assisted by a housing assistance program, or any bond history and claims
  • past South Australian Housing Trust tenancies
  • unredacted bank statements
  • bankruptcy discharge information
  • employment details beyond a payslip or employment confirmation
  • medical records
  • social media information
  • vehicle registration numbers or pet microchip numbers
  • education level
  • the applicant's reason for moving

The same regulation says financial information must not be requested primarily on the basis of the applicant's spending records. A statement that shows income and regular commitments is reasonable. A line-by-line review of how someone spends their money is not.

Two further points apply to the process. First, you cannot invite rent bidding: the SA Government's guidance says a landlord or agent cannot seek offers above the rent fixed in the agreement. Second, section 52B of the Act restricts third parties who are not the landlord's agent from providing tenant-suitability assessments based on rent offered. The maximum penalty is $20,000. Advertise one rent, and assess every applicant against that figure.

The two-document rule in practice

The cap on documents is easy to breach by habit. A common pattern is to ask for "anything else that helps", which can push a category past two documents. Decide in advance which two documents you accept for each category and state them on the listing.

CategoryExamples of acceptable documentsMaximum
IdentityDriver's licence, passport (at least one with a photo)2
Ability to pay rentRecent payslip, employment confirmation, redacted bank statement2
Suitability for the tenancyA document directly relating to the applicant's circumstances, as the form allows2

If an applicant supplies a bank statement, they can redact transactions that are not relevant to income. Treat a redacted statement as complete. Do not ask for the unredacted version because a figure is unclear; ask for a different permitted document in that category instead, provided you are still within the limit.

Our own guide to two-document affordability checks walks through how to document these decisions so they stand up if a dispute reaches SACAT, the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

Anti-discrimination: what must not influence the decision

The criteria you may lawfully assess, according to Equal Opportunity SA, are the applicant's ability to abide by the tenancy conditions, keep the property in good order and pay the rent. References from previous landlords or agents, payslips, Centrelink statements and bank statements are all legitimate tools for those three questions.

The same page lists characteristics that cannot lawfully shape a rental decision in SA:

  • the identity of a spouse or partner
  • sexual orientation, sex, gender identity and intersex status
  • race
  • pregnancy
  • marital or domestic partnership status
  • disability
  • caring responsibilities and association with a child
  • age

Guide dogs and assistance animals must be allowed even where pets are otherwise excluded. Equal Opportunity SA also advises landlords to check advertisements for discriminatory intent. A listing that says "professional couple preferred" or "suits mature tenants" can create a problem before any application arrives.

For a landlord who is not on site, such as an interstate investor, the practical risk is the informal conversation. A comment from an agent or a family member about whether a family or a young applicant "would suit" can be read as a reason for the decision. Written criteria, applied by trained staff, take that risk out.

Building criteria you can apply consistently

Equal Opportunity SA's advice is to process every application for a property in the same way, using the same criteria, and to make sure staff know those policies. A simple scoring sheet does this. Fix it before the property is listed.

1. Identity

Confirm the applicant is who they say they are, using the permitted documents. Pass or fail, with no scoring.

2. Ability to pay the rent

Use the two permitted documents to confirm that income covers the weekly rent with room for other commitments. Set one written affordability test and use it for every applicant. Lenders do the same with rental income, applying a fixed test to every property, as explained in this overview of how lenders test rental income. The principle carries over: the number is set in advance, not adjusted per person.

3. Rental history

Call the referees named on Form A1 and ask the same questions each time: was the rent paid on time, was the property kept in good order, was the routine inspection process cooperative? Record the answers. Do not ask about disputes, bond claims or why the person is moving, because the regulation excludes them.

4. Suitability for this property

Ask whether the number of occupants and the planned length of stay suit the property and the lease term you are offering. Keep the question about the property, not the person.

5. Record the decision

Write two lines on why the successful applicant met the criteria better than the next one. If the decision is ever challenged, a dated, factual record is stronger than a recollection.

Unsuccessful applicants' information also needs to be handled and destroyed within the required timeframe. Our guide to tenant privacy laws in SA sets out the obligations.

What about the 30% rental rule?

The 30% rule is a search term, not an SA legal test. It originates overseas: a commonly cited US version holds that rent should be no more than 30% of gross monthly income, and a related "3x rent" rule asks for income of at least three times the monthly rent. The American Apartment Owners Association describes both as first-pass screens before debt, credit and rental history are reviewed.

SA's framework works differently. The law limits you to two documents about ability to pay and bars requests based primarily on spending records. You may set an internal affordability benchmark, but it should be written, applied equally and tested against those documents. It should never become a reason to decline an applicant on grounds linked to a protected characteristic.

For a higher-rent property, the sensible approach is to set the benchmark with a margin and to weigh it together with rental history and references. Income alone does not tell you whether a tenant will pay on time and look after the home.

Where owners get caught

The most frequent problems we see described in SA tenancy guidance come from process, not intent:

  • Old application templates. A form that predates Form A1 may ask for items now excluded.
  • Too many documents. Asking for three payslips and two bank statements exceeds the cap for the ability-to-pay category.
  • Unwritten criteria. Without a standard, each decision depends on whoever happens to handle the file.
  • Advertising wording. Phrases that hint at a preferred age, family type or background.
  • Rent negotiation. Accepting offers above the advertised rent.

For wider obligations once a tenant is in place, our overview of Adelaide rental compliance requirements covers the next stage. The SACAT-ready tenant selection checklist gives a printable version of the scoring approach above, and our guide to tenant screening methods for SA landlords compares how each check contributes to the decision.

Premium homes in suburbs such as Unley, Glenelg, North Adelaide and Norwood tend to attract a larger pool of applicants, which makes a documented scoring process more valuable, not less. More applicants means more decisions to justify. Our guide to screening tenants for premium properties covers that situation.

Our view on tenant selection

A good application process does two jobs. It gets you a tenant who pays on time and looks after the property, and it leaves a record showing the decision was made on lawful grounds.

We manage residential property in Adelaide and do not handle sales, so tenant selection and compliance get our full attention. Our HPTS Tenant Screening is a 4-layer system, and we also offer a Drug Testing Service for owners who want it as part of selection.

Owners we work with, including interstate investors and busy professionals, usually want two things: confidence that the criteria are lawful, and visibility of what was decided. Our 24/7 owner portal is built for that second need.

The strongest position is simple. Criteria fixed in writing, one standard for every applicant, and a record of the reasoning.

HOSO

Let us run the application process

HOSO Real Estate handles tenant placement, rent collection, maintenance coordination, lease administration and inspections for Adelaide landlords. Applications are screened through our HPTS Tenant Screening, and a rental appraisal is the usual first step to set the advertised rent before listing. We also offer a 60-day satisfaction guarantee on our management service.

FAQ

What form do SA landlords use for rental applications?

South Australian applications must use Form A1. The form must state the weekly rent payable and the bond amount, if any. Using an older or custom form risks asking for information the regulations no longer allow.

How many documents can I ask a tenant for?

No more than two documents in each of three categories: identity, ability to pay rent, and suitability to enter the agreement. For identity, at least one should be a photo document. Financial requests are limited to items such as a redacted bank statement or a payslip.

Can I ask why an applicant is leaving their current home?

No. Regulation 8 lists the reason for moving among the information a landlord may not request. The same applies to past tenancy disputes, bond history and claims, and social media information. Stick to the referees and rental details on Form A1.

Can I choose the highest rent offer?

No. A landlord or agent in SA cannot invite rent bidding or seek offers above the fixed rent in the agreement. Advertise one rent figure and assess applicants against the same criteria.

Is there a 30% rule in South Australia?

Not as a legal test. The 30% and 3x benchmarks come from overseas screening practice. In SA you assess ability to pay using the permitted documents, applying one written standard to every applicant.

Sources